Click on right here for an entire record of our election suggestions.
For the reason that begin of the pandemic, Richmond Metropolis Council members have decimated the Police Division as a part of their defunding effort.
Police staffing ranges plunged 26% in a single yr, fewer crimes are being investigated, demoralized officers are working extreme time beyond regulation and fleeing the division for different jobs or retirement, and recruitment has slowed to a trickle as a result of few need to work in Richmond. In the meantime, there have been 18 homicides within the first 9 months of this yr, matching the whole lot of 2022.
The query for metropolis voters within the Nov. 8 election is, do they need to stick to the Richmond Progressive Alliance, which spearheaded the defunding effort after successful majority management of the council in 2020? The alliance must win simply one of many 4 seats on the poll to retain management.
Or do voters need to return to a extra considerate council majority that may begin rebuilding the Police Division? For that, voters ought to again Shawn Dunning for mayor, Cesar Zepeda for Metropolis Council in District 2, Oscar Garcia in District 3, and Soheila Bana in District 4.
If there’s any excellent news in Richmond, it’s that metropolis leaders are beginning to assault a few of the points that led the state auditor utilizing information from 2019-20 to rank Richmond the ninth worst on a listing of financially at-risk cities in California.
The council is working to succeed in a brand new 15%-20% funds reserve coverage, smaller than many cities however a serious enchancment over years previous when Richmond was barely capable of pay its payments. And town has lastly extracted itself from a expensive and ill-conceived bond deal that was supposed to assist town cowl a few of its pension obligations.
That stated, town nonetheless has super debt for the pension and retiree well being applications totaling about $500 million, an quantity equal to about seven years of metropolis payroll. That’s roughly the identical because it was seven years in the past.
40% discount in cops
The dangerous information is that the Metropolis Council majority’s effort to reimagine public security has considerably contributed to the sudden discount of cops on the streets and investigating crimes.
The division had skilled a gradual however regular decline in sworn officers, from 182 within the 2014-15 fiscal yr to 149 within the 2020-21 fiscal yr, when the RPA gained majority management and calls for to defund the police accelerated.
In June 2021, because it was making ready the funds for the 2021-22 fiscal yr, the Metropolis Council reduce the authorised positions for the already-shrunken division to 145 and trimmed $3 million from its funds. And it got here with the message that there could be extra cuts sooner or later to fund various public security measures.
That’s when cops started to flee and, within the 2021-22 fiscal yr, the sworn staffing stage plunged to 110, 26% fewer than the yr earlier than and a 40% discount from seven years earlier. With 15 injured or on mild obligation, that leaves about 95 cops obtainable at present. They’re working at the least 10 hours of necessary time beyond regulation every week. It’s a recipe for drained officers to make lethal errors.
Masking patrol beats leaves few officers for different duties. Whereas in 2014 there have been about 50 detectives to analyze crimes, at present there are 13. Instances are going unsolved. The division is reactive reasonably than proactive. It’s unsustainable.
We’ve been a passionate critic of police abuse, together with the Richmond division’s unjustifiable variety of canine bites. However the reply is to weed out the dangerous cops, not go away town’s residents unprotected.
Police Chief Bisa French has stated that if the council implements plans to supply civilian help for calls comparable to psychological well being issues and fender-bender accidents, the division would nonetheless want 165 officers, what it had simply three years in the past, to correctly handle crime and be attentive to the group.
However stopping cops from fleeing Richmond is unlikely and not using a new council majority.
Mayor – Shawn Dunning
With Tom Butt, who has unsuccessfully fought the police funds cuts, unable to run for mayor once more due to time period limits, two incumbent Metropolis Council members and two different candidates are vying for the highest job.
Dunning is a management marketing consultant who focuses on battle decision. And he needs to follow his commerce by being a bridge on the council between the 2 warring factions which have divided metropolis politics for years.
However don’t mistake him for some light-weight candidate. He was much more knowledgeable on particulars of metropolis funds and different points than the 2 incumbent Metropolis Council members within the race, Eduardo Martinez and Nat Bates.
Dunning needs to considerably enhance the variety of cops, however he additionally helps civilian crime prevention and psychological well being help in partnership with Contra Costa County, which has funding for such applications.
Martinez, who has served on the council eight years, struggled to reply whether or not he needs to rent extra cops, whereas Bates, 91, who says he’s the nation’s oldest elected public official in a metropolis of greater than 100,000 folks, needs extra officers. The fourth candidate, Mark Wassberg, who lives in his truck in El Sobrante and collects his mail in Richmond, didn’t attend the digital interview after saying he would.
District 2 – Cesar Zepeda
Zepeda, a member of the West County Wastewater District board who got here inside 44 votes of successful a Metropolis Council seat in 2018, helps the police chief’s aim to spice up staffing. He’s additionally aware of the funds implications of any modifications and understands town’s retirement debt, partially as a result of his day job is as a well being and advantages marketing consultant.
His opponent, Andrew Butt, an architect, former metropolis planning commissioner and son of the outgoing mayor, additionally backs hiring extra cops. Whereas Butt is sensible and well-informed, if the progressive alliance holds on to majority management, his bulldog strategy would seemingly go away him ineffectual at bridging the divide.
The town wants leaders who can attain calm compromise. Zepeda is the higher match to succeed in that aim.
District 3 – Oscar Garcia
The candidates on this race embody Corky Boozé, who was a disruptive pressure on the council from 2010-14 and isn’t temperamentally suited to confront the intense challenges forward.
Which leaves Oscar Garcia and Doria Robinson, each natives of the Iron Triangle neighborhood. Garcia, a Police Evaluate Fee member, is an environmental engineer for a renewable vitality agency. Robinson is the manager director of City Tilth, a non-profit that hires and trains native residents to domesticate agriculture.
Each are educated about and maintain comparable views on lots of the challenges going through town. However they differ on the massive subject, police staffing: Robinson, backed by the progressive alliance, needs to attend to resolve whether or not to trim or enhance the variety of officers. Garcia is evident that town wants extra cops. For that cause, we suggest Garcia.
District 4 – Soheila Bana
Bana, a Parks and Recreation Fee member, is a retired transportation engineer for Caltrans who led the Bay Space chapter of the state engineers union. She backs the police staffing ranges the chief says are essential. And he or she understands Richmond’s monetary challenges, together with the large unfunded retirement liabilities.
In distinction, Jamin Pursell, the progressive alliance candidate, dismisses the police staffing scarcity as no completely different from every other metropolis. He’s unsuitable. And relating to discussing town’s funds and, particularly, the unfunded retirement legal responsibility, he spouts out wildly inaccurate numbers and doesn’t perceive how authorities pensions work.
Bana is the far superior candidate on this race.
