Opinion: Why the fossil fuel divestment movement should reach hospitals


I selected a profession in drugs as a result of I needed to work someplace with a powerful moral basis. It was the identical purpose I spent years concerned within the antiwar motion and taking motion on local weather change — which is now a priority throughout the career.

Hospitals have pledged to decrease operational carbon emissions. A number of main public physicians, together with Nationwide Academy of Drugs president Victor Dzau, wrote within the New England Journal of Drugs: “Though many individuals take into account local weather change a looming risk, well being issues stemming from it already kill tens of millions of individuals per 12 months.” And a survey within the Lancet discovered that 91% of well being professionals are nervous about local weather change.

Which is why I believe a lot of them could be shocked to learn the way a lot of our personal retirement cash is invested in fossil fuels — the largest drivers of local weather chaos.

The First Do No Hurt marketing campaign, in collaboration with the Local weather Protected Pensions Community and Stand.earth, just lately launched a report inspecting the pension funds of 4 outstanding non-public hospital methods: Kaiser Permanente, Mayo Clinic Well being Methods, HCA Healthcare and Ascension. We discovered that these 4 hospital networks alone have invested not less than $4.6 billion in fossil fuels and estimate that privately owned U.S. hospitals have effectively over $10 billion invested within the fossil gas economic system.

Kaiser Permanente, for instance, has $80.2 million invested in Suncor Power, among the many world’s largest producers of environmentally harmful “tar sands” oil, which produces not less than 17% extra carbon air pollution than typical crude oil. The Mayo Clinic, usually referred to as America’s greatest hospital, has over $40 million invested straight in fossil gas manufacturing giants, together with Exxon Mobil and Conoco Phillips.

I consider hospitals ship monumental advantages to their communities, and I do know they’ve a monetary accountability to their pensioners and traders. However they’re making a giant mistake — for his or her steadiness sheets and their sufferers’ well being — by investing in fossil fuels.

To start out with, these investments are a nasty wager financially. Regardless of a short lived surge in costs after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, long-term analyses of the inventory market clarify that the financial prospects of the fossil gas trade are grim. The trade has been unable to disclaim that the financial shift to renewable vitality has begun. The worth of fossil gas corporations is poised for a crash because the world will get critical about limiting using oil, coal and pure gasoline. It’s only a query of when.

However much more vital is the position these investments play in local weather change, of which fossil gas corporations are each the largest driver and the largest obstacles to options. These corporations have spent billions lobbying the federal government to gradual local weather motion and lied for many years about local weather science and about their plans to cease polluting.

In that point, local weather change has develop into a well being disaster. The Nationwide Academy of Drugs calls it “one of the crucial important threats to human well being within the twenty first century.”

Well being impacts from world warming and the continued burning of fossil fuels already declare 13 million lives yearly from environmental components together with air air pollution, illness and excessive climate occasions like California’s devastating wildfires. Scientists warn that persevering with the established order may result in temperatures rising by greater than 4 levels Celsius (7.2 levels Fahrenheit), leading to cataclysmic ranges of mass hunger and demise. That’s the longer term these hospitals are at the moment investing in, though they are going to be on the entrance strains of coping with the results.

These sorts of adversarial well being impacts are what motivated the well being trade’s final main divestment push, towards tobacco within the Nineteen Eighties and ’90s. The trade’s management led to Massive Tobacco corporations shedding a lot of their political clout in Washington.

Drawing on that mannequin, college college students launched a fossil gas motion a decade in the past that has grown into a strong arm of the local weather motion. Some 1,590 establishments have dedicated to types of fossil gas divestment, totaling a staggering $40.5 trillion of belongings below administration. It has expanded past college campuses to incorporate native governments, foundations, banks and funding companies. Since 2021 alone, establishments similar to Harvard College, the cities of Baltimore and Chicago, and the Ford and MacArthur foundations have dedicated to divestment, citing a conflict between fossil gas extraction and their elementary mission.

Hospitals ought to divest from fossil fuels for a similar purpose. We have to acknowledge that these investments essentially oppose our healthcare mission. We’d like establishments such because the Nationwide Academy of Drugs to name out fossil gas corporations as risks to human well being and supply management on how and why to include fossil gas divestment into current local weather change commitments throughout our trade.

The healthcare sector is able to miracles. We mapped the human genome. We conduct microsurgery. We will — and should — divest from the fossil fuels which are sickening our sufferers and our world.

Don Lieber is a surgical technician, nursing unit coordinator and director of the First Do No Hurt marketing campaign for fossil gas divestment within the well being sector.