Opinion | The Young Men of the Crick: Unfinished Lives on the Arizona-Utah Border


Several years into photographing the unorthodox residential structure of members of the F.L.D.S. alongside the Arizona-Utah border, I crossed paths with an 18-year-old former F.L.D.S. member named Jobee Cooke.

Earlier than assembly him, Quick Creek was all however impenetrable to me. After I arrived for the primary time in 2014, the F.L.D.S. nonetheless had a stronghold on the neighborhood, and I used to be tailed by vans with tinted blackout home windows. Even a couple of years later, the dominance of the F.L.D.S. in varied Utah and Arizona municipalities was severely weakened. After Mr. Jeffs was sentenced to life in jail, the environment of paranoia and suspicion that I first encountered was tempered. And the younger males whom Mr. Jeffs had as soon as banished from the houses of his followers have been now seen.

Jobee is one among a tight-knit group of youngsters and younger males navigating life after the F.L.D.S. In a polygamous cult, younger males are sometimes expendable. Jobee, like so many different younger males dwelling within the Crick, didn’t get a conventional training however as an alternative mastered expertise of horsemanship and survival. Assembly him grew to become my means of understanding the neighborhood, simply on the time he was working to discover a place for himself on this planet.

Jobee supplied to introduce me to the opposite boys, who, of their function of modern-day cowboys, explored the rugged terrain of southern Utah, northern Arizona and southern Nevada on horseback, capturing weapons and dressing up like old-time explorers of the Western frontier. Seemingly unaware of the backdrop of trauma inflicted by colonial enlargement on their Indigenous neighbors, the Paiute Indian Tribe, Jobee and his mates use role-playing to precise their newfound freedom and to deal with their rejection by the church. In each their actual and imaginary lives, they’ve gained a data of and closeness to nature that has been misplaced within the conventions of contemporary life.

I used to be initially drawn to the boys’ homes, with their uncommon add-ons and lacking siding. Surrounded by tall fences and mirrored home windows, these compounds characterize the occupants’ mistrust of the skin world and their bent for self-governance. Their houses are a reminder of the reclusive world they got here from and a counterpoint to their present autonomy.

The topics of those pictures inhabit a singular area within the desert expanses and open skies of the American West, suspended between hell and paradise. I hope that these pictures supply a bridge between our world and theirs.

Jim Mangan is a 2023 Mild Work artist-in-Residence who resides in Los Angeles, after spending 24 years within the mountains of Colorado and Utah. His ebook, “The Crick,” is forthcoming.

Judith Freeman is a novelist and nonfiction author who lives in Idaho and Los Angeles. Her latest undertaking, a collaboration with the photographer Tina Barney, might be printed subsequent yr.

The Occasions is dedicated to publishing a variety of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you concentrate on this or any of our articles. Listed here are some ideas. And right here’s our electronic mail: letters@nytimes.com.

Comply with The New York Occasions Opinion part on Fb, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram.