Opinion | LK-99 May Not Be a Room-Temperature Superconductor, but What if It Were?


The previous three weeks have witnessed the dramatic rise and fall of a brand new candidate for the holy grail of supplies science: a superconductor that works at room temperature. On July 22, a workforce of researchers in South Korea reported their findings on a compound they referred to as LK-99, claiming that its discovery was a “model new historic second” that might “open a brand new period for mankind.” A boisterous frenzy of on-line physics discussions and rapid-fire publications adopted, solely to fall flat two weeks later. LK-99, it appeared, was a bust.

The general public curiosity round LK-99 was a social phenomenon as a lot as a scientific one. The sheer quantity of on-line discussions on message boards, group chats, Reddit and X, the app previously often called Twitter, introduced the eye of analysis scientists who started working simulations and experiments to copy or refute the Korean workforce’s claims. For a quick second, a big viewers of individuals new to superconductivity discovered sudden fascination with a distinct segment space of supplies science, in search of a solution to a not often heard but profound query: Had humanity simply entered a brand new golden age?

Each time electrical energy runs via a transmission line, some is misplaced as waste warmth, an omnipresent tax imposed by the legal guidelines of nature. The miraculous potential of superconductors is that they carry electrical energy over massive distances with excellent effectivity. If we ever determine learn how to manufacture them cheaply and make them work at room temperature fairly than solely at tons of of levels under zero, it might revolutionize our economic system and assist save the surroundings. Superconductors may obtain feats like highly effective magnetic fields and levitation in midair, enabling new classes of digital units, computer systems and modes of transportation.

Sadly, the best temperature materials presently recognized to superconduct solely does so at -10 levels whereas needing to be put underneath a strain of round 1.9 million atmospheres. Supplies that superconduct at ambient strain require temperatures under roughly -150 levels, limiting their use to purposes the place the cryogenic engineering is price it, like medical imaging and experimental physics.

These properties are made potential in superconductors by the way in which electrons transfer in another way via them than they do via widespread metals. In copper and different electrically conductive supplies, think about a ball {of electrical} present dropped into the highest of a Plinko machine, bouncing on pegs all the way in which down. Every bounce transfers a little bit of vitality from the ball to a peg — that’s the warmth tax at work. In a superconductor, the balls {of electrical} present glide easily, like marbles alongside a observe. No warmth, no misplaced vitality.

Room-temperature superconductors would have the best affect on vitality technology, transmission and distribution. At present, 8 % to fifteen % of all vitality produced for electrical grids is misplaced as waste warmth en path to getting used. In the USA, this provides as much as dozens of nuclear energy vegetation price of wasted energy. Utilizing room-temperature superconductors in electrical transformers, which decrease excessive voltages in transmission strains to ranges acceptable for house use, and mills, which convert rotational vitality into electrical energy, may save one other 30 % to 40 % of wasted energy whereas decreasing the quantity and complexity of supplies it takes to make such gear within the first place.

Superconducting transmission strains would additionally allow close to lossless switch of renewable vitality over huge distances. Energy generated by large photo voltaic arrays within the West Coast deserts may extra simply gas East Coast cities all through the winter, and superconductor-based vitality storage may exchange industrial-scale batteries fully, fixing one of many essential challenges in growing renewable vitality at scale. These storage methods work by letting electrical present journey in an limitless loop, and because it does so with nearly no losses, it could proceed circling this loop with little or no energy used to maintain it going. The overall vitality misplaced when charging and discharging a traditional battery is round 20 %, whereas in such a superconducting storage system, it might be nearer to five %.

Low-temperature superconductors are used right now in purposes requiring highly effective magnetic fields, reminiscent of M.R.I. machines. A major contributor to the expense of these machines is the liquid helium wanted to chill the magnets all the way down to cryogenic temperatures. Every M.R.I. machine requires about 500 gallons of helium to function, and the restricted, fluctuating provide costs of helium can drive up the value and restrict the supply of M.R.I.s to sufferers in want.

The decision restrict of M.R.I. scans is decided by the energy of the magnetic discipline, and superconductors can produce very sturdy magnetic fields. Cheaper machines that function with out cryogenic cooling have been proposed, however they’d have a a lot decrease decision with out superconductors, limiting their skill to detect small however necessary well being situations. Room-temperature superconductors would remedy each of those challenges. Cheaper, extra accessible, and better decision, noninvasive medical imaging may rework the standard of diagnostic medical care — significantly in poorer international locations which have much less entry to M.R.I.s right now.

Excessive-strength magnetic fields produced by superconductors may also be used commercially to levitate high-speed trains on a skinny cushion of air above the tracks. This know-how has been in improvement in Japan for many years, with maglev trains initially projected to open to the general public in 2027, working at speeds as much as 375 miles per hour between Tokyo and Nagoya. In the USA, a maglev practice line has lately been proposed to hold commuters between New York Metropolis and Washington, D.C., in underneath an hour.

These specialised trains are extremely pricey to construct and troublesome to engineer due to our present superconducting supplies, limiting their utility to solely the world’s busiest and densest commuter corridors. Room-temperature superconductors would drastically simplify the design and engineering of high-speed trains, reaching speeds that might make rail aggressive with airways for continental intercity journey. As a bonus, these trains may run off clear, superconductor-enabled grid vitality, eliminating the 1000’s of kilos of carbon dioxide emitted to hold the passengers on a home flight.

The transistors that energy all fashionable electronics have limitations: They’ll solely function so quick, and each operation loses vitality as warmth. The pace of transistor operations of laptop chips steadily elevated till the mid-2010s, when it reached the fabric limits of our present silicon-based transistors. The density of transistors in a contemporary laptop chip can also be closely restricted by our skill to take away waste warmth, which is why chips are small, flat rectangles, usually with massive warmth sinks connected to the highest, as an alternative of stable cubes.

Laptop chips designed with superconducting supplies have the potential to be round 300 occasions as vitality environment friendly and 10 occasions as quick as our present silicon-based microelectronics. Eliminating waste warmth would allow extra compact designs, longer battery lives and a decrease tax on our electrical grid to energy the digital economic system. Lastly, we may go away as many browser tabs open as we wish.

Probably the most thrilling position room-temperature superconductors would possibly play in our future economic system is within the manufacturing of low-cost, clear vitality. The latest emergence of privately funded nuclear fusion tasks has largely been enabled by advances in manufacturing high-temperature superconducting tape, which generates the extraordinarily highly effective magnetic fields that lure and confine a scorching, charged fuel referred to as plasma at over 180 million levels. A room-temperature superconductor manufactured from extensively accessible low-cost metals would dramatically speed up the timeline to exchange our most harmful and polluting types of vitality — coal and oil — with fusion vitality, which works by the identical precept that powers the solar.

Fusion vitality, if it ever arrives, is alleged to be the final energy supply humanity will ever want. For the reason that gas for fusion might be extracted from seawater, it might free our vitality provides from the geopolitical turmoil that sends shocks to our economic system sometimes via the oscillating costs of oil and pure fuel. For a way of scale, the hydrogen from one gallon of seawater, when burned in a fusion reactor, releases roughly the identical quantity of vitality as over 1,000 gallons of refined gasoline. Limitless, conflict-free, carbon-free vitality would scale back the price of virtually each half or product, since half the value of widespread supplies like metal and aluminum is the price of the electrical energy it takes to make them.


Our central dilemma within the fashionable, environmentally aware world is that we should be taught to do extra with much less. The engine of our economic system calls for fixed development to maintain itself. But we additionally acknowledge the necessity to cut back our affect on the world round us and defend the ailing surroundings. Our incentives and obligations to the fabric world are pulling us in several instructions. The attract of a room-temperature superconductor grows as our financial and environmental image darkens. It’s the type of miracle materials that would sluggish local weather change whereas supercharging international financial prosperity, realized via new applied sciences beforehand solely seen in science fiction.

In latest days scientists have revealed a number of new experiences displaying that LK-99 isn’t a superconductor at room temperature however fairly a reasonably mundane magnetic substance that mimics among the visible properties attribute of superconductors, like levitating over a robust magnet, however not an important bodily property of zero electrical resistance. Somewhat than placing gold, the Korean scientists most likely found a brand new type of pyrite.

We nonetheless don’t know whether or not the sector of superconductivity analysis will profit from the brand new avenues opened up in the previous couple of weeks if many labs proceed to analyze supplies much like LK-99. It’s a discipline the place idea and experiment have usually challenged one another, and our expectations of what’s potential have ceaselessly been questioned by what has been noticed. Though public curiosity will little question fade for now, a daring promise stays: a superconducting golden age is likely to be simply over the horizon, and the position of science is obvious — to discover a solution to get us there.

Illustrations by Taylor Maggiacomo.