Click on right here for an entire checklist of our election suggestions.
Oakland voters are being requested to double down on a misleading and ill-planned roads-repair program that has blown via value projections with no sign of ending — a plan that may saddle property house owners with greater than $1 billion of tax debt over the following 4 many years.
Sadly, Measure U on the Nov. 8 poll ties the roads program to an inexpensive housing funding plan that, had it been standing alone on the poll, would deserve critical consideration. However the roads and housing proposals, together with funding to rehabilitate metropolis amenities, are packaged collectively into one poll measure. Voters ought to reject it.
They need to ship a message that, with robust common fund tax revenues, metropolis leaders have to cease reflexively making an attempt to succeed in into the pockets of property house owners for much more cash each election yr.
The difficulty will not be whether or not the town wants more cash to repair its badly dilapidated roads. It does. The difficulty is that, when metropolis leaders ask for brand spanking new taxes, they should include clear budgets that guarantee the cash will likely be properly spent — and information that display previous tax revenues have been used effectively.
That’s fully missing with the roads portion of Measure U, a fiscally irresponsible $850 million bond measure that may allocate $290 million towards streets, $350 million for inexpensive housing and $210 million for metropolis amenities. Measure U could be piled on prime of Measure KK, a $600 million bond measure permitted in 2016 for a similar three makes use of. It’s clear now, six years later, that Measure KK was grossly oversold and has barely made a dent in bettering the general situation of the town’s streets.
Mixed, the bond measures would complete $1.45 billion. However bonds are a type of borrowing that property house owners should pay again — with curiosity. Paying off Measure KK and Measure U bonds would value the town’s property house owners almost $3 billion, of which almost half could be for roads. These taxes drive up the value of housing for householders and renters, whose landlords ultimately go on the price.
Property house owners are simply starting to repay the Measure KK bonds, which by 2026 will value the proprietor of a house assessed at $500,000 about $190 a yr. If the Measure U bonds are added in, the property tax funds would soar to roughly $500 yearly early within the subsequent decade. Double these numbers for properties assessed at $1 million.
Poll deceit
For all that spending, metropolis officers ought to a minimum of be straight up with voters about the usage of the cash. After a metropolis survey earlier this yr confirmed that crime was the highest concern for Oakland voters and that Measure U may have a troublesome time passing, the poll wording was altered to start by claiming it might “enhance public security.”
To be clear, Measure U has nothing to do with public security within the sense of lowering crime or bolstering the town’s badly depleted police power, which by the top of final yr hit the bottom degree in seven years. Nor wouldn’t it handle the town’s murder price, which in 2021 was the best since 2006 — and is on tempo this yr to match that.
Moderately, Measure U is a mashup of three unrelated funding areas that metropolis officers have melded below the rubric of infrastructure. The weather ought to have been cut up so voters had the possibility to determine individually whether or not they wished to assist inexpensive housing, road repaving and/or metropolis amenities. They shouldn’t face an all-or-nothing resolution.
However that combo technique labored efficiently for metropolis officers in 2016 when 82% of voters permitted Measure KK, championed by Mayor Libby Schaaf. On the time, Schaaf was finishing her first two years in workplace after inheriting a backlog of deferred upkeep and liabilities, most notably the town’s failure to correctly preserve its roads.
For many years, metropolis officers had patched potholes whereas letting surrounding pavement proceed to crumble. Measure KK contained $350 million for street repairs. Oakland officers claimed that cash would cowl a lot of the $443 million paving backlog the town stated it had on the time. It’s for that motive that we backed the measure.
Unfilled guarantees
It’s clear now that the issue was worse than metropolis officers portrayed it and that they’ve barely begun to ship on their guarantees. Six years after Measure KK was handed, Oakland nonetheless has a number of the worst roads within the Bay Space. The typical situation of the town’s streets, measured final yr, has barely modified from 2015.
In the meantime, nobody has bothered to even analyze whether or not the town has been spending the Measure KK cash effectively, beginning with how Oakland’s road-repair value per mile compares to different Bay Space cities.
A advisor’s report accomplished in April concluded that the town now must spend $898 million on pavement upkeep and rehabilitation over the following 20 years to restore its streets to allow them to then be maintained with ongoing preventive upkeep. That ought to be the aim. However metropolis officers couldn’t present a funds for getting there, for the way a lot could be coated by annual street upkeep cash the town receives from the state and the county and has in its personal common fund, and the way far more property house owners ought to be anticipated to kick in.
Plainly, after promising six years in the past to restore a lot of the metropolis streets with Measure KK, metropolis officers are on the lookout for a daily and infinite collection of bond measures that may saddle future generations with debt. Certainly, with Measure U, the town plans to stretch the bond funds over 40 years, a decade longer than a typical dwelling mortgage. The unconscionably prolonged time period, like several long-term mortgage, would drive up the curiosity prices for taxpayers. It’s fiscally reckless.
