Migrants love NY – but at what cost to NYers!


The migrant disaster is draining our restricted sources, and there’s no finish in sight. 

As 1000’s flood throughout our border and discover their method to New York, our state and federal politicians are doing their greatest to faux this disaster isn’t taking place. Gov. Hochul is asleep on the wheel. Sens. Chuck Schumer and Kirsten Gillibrand have been keen to throw cash on the drawback, however even that has dried up. 

They provide no long-term resolution aside from legalizing all 11 million unlawful immigrants.

Since final spring, when the Texas and Florida governors started busing migrants to New York Metropolis, we’ve got acquired about 55,000. This implies we’ve taken on extra migrants than the inhabitants of Center Village, which I characterize. However extra come each day. 

Finite sources

Whereas a New Yorker’s love is infinite, our cash and infrastructure are finite. Town expects to spend $4.3 billion on migrants in solely two fiscal years, which is $100 million greater than the estimate from just some weeks in the past. 

On the identical time, the mayor moved municipal retirees to Medicare Benefit as a cost-saving measure, and metropolis businesses are dealing with a 4% price range lower. 


Hotel 46, 129 West 46th Street, New York, NY.
Town expects to spend $4.3 billion on migrants in solely two fiscal years.
Gregory P. Mango

About 32,600 migrants at the moment are in 100 emergency shelters. In just some weeks, our shelters took on a further 5,000 migrants and had to make use of 16 extra inns to accommodate them. About $300 a day is spent per individual in an emergency shelter. 

The lodging are higher than what former service members obtain on the veterans shelter on Borden Avenue. Metropolis immigration courts are backlogged, with greater than 124,000 circumstances pending. New York Metropolis’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement subject workplace is booked by October 2033 for migrant appointments. 

It will likely be years earlier than asylum seekers see a decide. The present stage of migration into our metropolis and the sources it takes to look after them are unsustainable.

No different nation on the planet permits simply anybody to indicate up and acquire entry to all their nation’s sources. 

Focused immigration based mostly on labor-market wants would enable for a more practical melting pot and alleviate some labor shortages, reminiscent of nurses and different health-care employees. As an alternative, we’ve got supposed “asylum seekers,” regardless that actuality says the overwhelming majority of migrants are single males in search of work. 


Kathy Hochul
Kathy Hochul didn’t point out the migrant disaster in her State of the State tackle.
Matthew McDermott

Biden is MIA

Sadly, the Biden administration is MIA. Not solely are Republican governors sending migrants to New York Metropolis, however even the Democratic Colorado governor, Jared Polis, despatched us migrants till Mayor Adams intervened. The Biden administration ought to embrace the “Stay in Mexico” coverage, which was profitable throughout the Trump administration. 

Inexplicably, Hochul didn’t point out the migrant disaster in her State of the State tackle. Though she pledged $1 billion in her price range, cash will not be sufficient, neither is this quantity assured. The share of state and federal funds housing the homeless is reducing whereas town’s share is growing. 

Because the disaster continues, states will benefit from New York’s sanctuary standing and right-to-shelter legal guidelines. Gillibrand’s solely concept is to switch New York Metropolis’s migrant drawback to the remainder of the state. After upstate leaders pushed again, she stopped speaking in regards to the concept.

Everybody is aware of the established order will not be working, but we regularly hear the identical outdated concept — throw extra tax {dollars} on the drawback. 

On the subject of migrants, we don’t manage to pay for, and even when we did, we might nonetheless have tens of 1000’s of idle people, primarily single males, making an attempt to outlive illegally in our nation. 

Earlier than every other coverage will get applied, we should get management who enters our nation. We’d like our flesh pressers to behave like leaders, acknowledge actuality and repair the southern border now.

Robert Holden is a Democratic New York Metropolis councilmember representing District 30 in Queens.