Elon Musk gutting Twitter would be a threat to us all


With Elon Musk on the verge of taking up Twitter Inc. comes information that he plans to intestine its workforce, with cuts of as much as 75%. That must be a fear not solely to the platform’s workers and customers, however for many who care concerning the movement of knowledge essential to well-functioning democracies.

Musk, who can also be the chief government officer of carmaker Tesla Inc. and area transport firm House Exploration Applied sciences Corp., plans to whittle Twitter down from 7,500 workers to simply over 2,000, The Washington Submit reported Thursday, citing paperwork and folks conversant in the plans. Whereas the 51-year-old had tried to again out of deal, the transaction appears like it can truly proceed with a court-issued deadline of Oct. 28.

But even with out the takeover, Twitter itself had deliberate to trim its workforce by a couple of quarter by the top of subsequent yr, the Submit reported. Past workers, the San Francisco-based social media firm can also be main cuts to infrastructure equivalent to information facilities, the newspaper wrote. Twitter informed workers later the identical day that it has no plans for company-wide layoffs.

“We should not have any affirmation of the client’s plans following shut and advocate not following rumors or leaked paperwork however slightly watch for information from us and the client instantly,” Twitter Common Counsel Sean Edgett wrote in a memo seen by Bloomberg Information following the report. Bloomberg Information confirmed that potential buyers have been informed of the plan for cuts, together with an effort to double income inside three years.

Feedback made by Musk, each private and non-private, point out that the world’s richest man needs to renovate the platform, its content material, and its enterprise mannequin. There’s additionally a way of disdain towards the corporate and its group: he’s publicly criticized selections made by senior workers.

Lots of Musk’s gripes are professional. Bots and faux accounts actually are an issue, although maybe to not the extent he claims. The enterprise mannequin is flawed — it has over 200 million customers however struggles to remain worthwhile — and safety practices are sub-par.

However hollowing out the group to the extent of a skeleton crew gained’t repair any of that.

Financial downturns are usually a very good excuse for executives to chop their workforces, and this imminent recession appears set to repeat the pattern. Microsoft Corp. lately introduced layoffs, and subsequent week’s earnings season would be the good cowl for others to observe go well with. Meta Platforms Inc., higher often called Fb, has hinted it plans to trim its headcount.

That mentioned, slashing 75% of workers isn’t the sort of surgical strike geared toward tidying up a bloated workforce and getting an organization by just a few quarters of tough climate. It’s a slash-and-burn tactic akin to private-equity buyers hurriedly attempting to spice up the underside line with little regard for the long-term way forward for the corporate.

Such an perspective is bewildering. Musk, who will take the corporate personal and personal it outright, has a web value of virtually $200 billion. Whereas solely a fraction of that’s liquid — most being tied up in shares of his firms — Twitter’s $3.8 billion annual working finances is one thing he may afford to bolster, not cut back.

And if he’s to undertake even half the reforms he’s proposed — like dealing with the bot downside, verifying customers, and constructing a brand new tremendous app — Twitter will want extra workers, not fewer.

It’s not a standard firm although. In his personal phrases, Twitter is “the de facto public city sq.” which might make him town mayor. And given its position in disseminating information and knowledge, Musk will in impact be the editor-in-chief of one of many world’s strongest information retailers.

We’ve already been granted a sneak preview of his editorial bent. He’s acknowledged he’d reverse the ban on Donald Trump after the outgoing president fomented a riot and assault on the US Capitol constructing, calling the expulsion “silly within the excessive.” That’s a professional debate, and revisiting the choice is a worthwhile train even when it leads to a continuation of that exclusion.

But a few of his different musings have raised eyebrows. Earlier this month, he tweeted an ill-advised ballot on Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, together with his proposal soundly defeated. He coupled that with ill-informed feedback about Taiwan and China in an interview with the Monetary Occasions. It’s telling that Beijing’s ambassador to the US thanked him, and value remembering that China accounts for 26% of Tesla’s annual gross sales and hosts one among its largest factories.

His latest pro-Russia feedback and threats to cease supplying Starlink satellite tv for pc service to Ukraine are among the many causes for the US authorities to contemplate subjecting Musk’s offers, together with the Twitter takeover, to nationwide safety evaluate, Bloomberg Information reported Thursday. That the consortium to purchase Twitter contains Saudi, Qatari and Chinese language buyers gives additional trigger for concern, it reported.

Company leaders ought to have opinions, and never be afraid to specific them. Communications groups and public-image consultants have skilled executives to be bland and apolitical, whereas those self same firms quietly spend tens of millions of {dollars} lobbying politicians to enact legal guidelines that go well with their enterprise and political pursuits. Not less than with Musk, we all know the place he stands — even when that stance could generally seem imprudent.

With Twitter, although, Musk strikes from being a high-profile, extraordinarily talkative chief of a few transportation firms to the overlord of a particularly highly effective and extremely efficient instrument for disseminating each information and disinformation. Whereas Twitter must sooner or later earn a living, it can seemingly by no means be as precious as Tesla or SpaceX, which makes it extra like a interest challenge and labor of affection.

A considerable amount of that keenness will have to be devoted to maintaining a lid on automated accounts (bots) and disingenuous customers (trolls), whereas attempting to not overreach to the purpose of unwarranted censorship. It’s an issue not distinctive to Twitter. Fb, LinkedIn and even TikTok face related struggles in controlling disinformation, and it’s a difficulty that can solely escalate in coming years as on-line platforms play an growing position within the movement of concepts essential to well-functioning democracies.

To attain any of the objectives Musk claims to have for Twitter he’ll want a succesful and well-resourced group desperate to make the corporate higher and the platform stronger. Slashing workers and hollowing out the workforce could be a transparent indication that the mayor of the general public city sq. isn’t a lot fascinated about maintaining the peace, however permitting barbarians within the gate.