Editorial: Drought and flood, California’s double whammy


Simply as federal officers had been laying out various situations final week for steep water provide cuts from the Colorado River because of the drying Southwest, California officers had been warning that this 12 months’s historic Sierra snowpack might flood a lot of the state later this 12 months.

So do we’ve an excessive amount of water or not sufficient? The one sincere reply, as head-spinning as it might be, is that we’ve each issues on the similar time. Lake Mead, and farther up the Colorado River, Lake Powell — Southern California’s two huge out-of-state water provides — stay dangerously low and won’t fill once more, regardless of a moist Rocky Mountain winter.

In the meantime, reservoirs in California are full. However a lot of that treasured water must be launched to make room for melting snow. How a lot room relies on climate situations over the following a number of months. The state has one in every of its largest snowpacks in recorded historical past — 234% of common, measured by water quantity, and in some components of the Sierra greater than 300% — however a lot of it might immediately flip to floodwater if we get a type of monstrous warmth waves we’ve skilled lately. Or it might evaporate proper off the mountainsides, leaving us nothing. Or, with luck, it might soften steadily over the summer time.

State water officers predict that Lake Tahoe will probably be 3 toes deeper by summer time’s finish and that historic Tulare Lake, making a uncommon reappearance this 12 months after its waters had been diverted for agriculture a century in the past, might develop giant sufficient to threaten properties in San Joaquin Valley cities akin to Corcoran and may stick round for 2 years or extra. The San Joaquin and Tuolumne rivers will run at greater than twice their common volumes later this 12 months.

The final twenty years have introduced local weather patterns fairly completely different from these round which the Western United States was engineered within the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Moist years at the moment are transient breaks in an prolonged period of aridification. Dams and aqueducts constructed for wetter instances nonetheless serve us however now not suffice. The identical is true of our system of water rights, rules and agreements. All are outmoded.

We as soon as had sufficient reservoirs in place to retailer ample water to see us by means of the occasional dry winter and seize sufficient runoff and snowmelt to guard us from flooding. However no variety of dams can maintain again sufficient water to outlast a 10-year drought or shield us from cataclysmic flooding.

And the sobering fact is that California’s latest dry streaks haven’t but matched the two-decade drought underway within the Colorado River Basin — however they might. The flooding we’re getting this spring, and that might worsen later this 12 months, is a mere trace of what we will count on from a so-called ARKstorm (for Atmospheric River 1,000). The final such megastorm got here within the winter of 1862 and put a lot of the San Joaquin Valley — and a superb chunk of Los Angeles — underwater. Scientists say we’ll be getting a type of once more, though they will’t say when.

None of which means it’s time to pack up and depart. The California of the foreseeable future will proceed to be a remarkably livable place, maybe with fewer almond and pistachio orchards, as a result of these bushes can’t survive weeks of soaking roots in moist instances and since there will probably be inadequate water to maintain them alive in dry instances.

Some valley landowners might observe the lead of ranchers who bought their land to organizations akin to River Companions. That group’s Dos Rios floodplain restoration challenge on the confluence of the San Joaquin and Tuolumne rivers west of Modesto is an efficient template for the longer term — with river-adjacent land the place floodwaters might be directed in years like this one, doing no injury to properties or crops, replenishing the depleted groundwater, restoring native vegetation and nurturing juvenile fish and different wildlife.

In Los Angeles and different cities accustomed to infinite water provides from the Colorado River, we might lastly surrender our lawns, the thirsty crop that’s by no means harvested or consumed.

There might be sufficient water to go round if we deal with it as the precious and typically harmful factor that it’s. We will climate the wet-and-dry, boom-and-bust cycle that nature throws at us if we surrender our nostalgia for the extra predictable California of the previous and embrace the state as it’s now and as it should change into.