Cabinet wants to set strict requirements for online age verification systems – IT Pro – News

Door GurbieV:

Good concept. From when can we do an age examine with digid or superb?

It is a dangerous concept, as a result of it is hardly going to work and it additionally has critical damaging penalties.

The purpose shouldn’t be for over-18s to show that they’re 18+, however to stop under-17s from having the ability to show that they’re 18+.

If you’re 16, and have develop into hooked on on-line playing after the wave of promoting, and you’ll quickly must show that you’re 18+ at a few of the playing websites, are you going to stay to the principles and cease playing?

Or do you search for unlawful websites that aren’t so tough (but in addition do nothing to mood your playing habit), or do you copy the passport of your grandfather (who doesn’t have a smartphone) in your smartphone? Or do you borrow the ID of an older brother or boyfriend?

Do you suppose underneath 17s can be severely punished in the event that they commit identification fraud? In reality, if individuals (together with younger individuals) consider that they unjustly are neglected, they begin flouting the principles. Criminalizing them could make their conduct go from dangerous to worse. This results in extra polarization and a lower in confidence within the authorities.

Pure disk safety. Reliable absolute authenticeren can solely”in individualif the information topic has a legitimate ID and the verifier completely checks for indications of tampering or of an entire forgery (with growing AI, “on-line authentication” is changing into more and more idiotic).

Final however not least: if individuals over the age of 18 must show on-line, as reliably as doable, that they’re “sufficiently old”, verifiers will get their palms on extra privacy-sensitive information.

So very undesirable.