All of the challenges facing NYC’s legal marijuana efforts


I’m the founding father of Gotham, a authorized hashish idea retailer. I emphasize the phrase authorized as a result of, regardless of what most New Yorkers in all probability assume, there are presently solely seven authorized hashish dispensaries in all of New York Metropolis. The hundreds of different outlets you see on nearly each nook are unlicensed, unregulated, and unlawful. 

New York State had good intentions once they rolled out the primary alternatives to use for a authorized dispensary license final November. The primary licenses have been made accessible solely to these previously incarcerated for hashish offenses and to nonprofit organizations that help and uplift this cohort. The concept was to create a hashish business that makes an attempt to proper the wrongs of the failed conflict on medication. 

I applaud the state for these efforts. Bu that imaginative and prescient is much from actuality. A whole lot of licenses have been issued, however few shops have really open. It isn’t simple to get a lease attributable to stigma or insurance coverage considerations, and adhering to guidelines and laws is expensive. 


A rare sight: NYC's authorities seize an unauthorized weed truck in Brooklyn back in September of 2022. The author says even stricter enforcement efforts are needed.
A uncommon sight: NYC’s authorities seize an unauthorized weed truck in Brooklyn again in September of 2022. The writer says even stricter enforcement efforts are wanted.
Paul Martinka

The largest subject for individuals who have opened, akin to Gotham, is making an attempt to compete in an oversaturated unlawful panorama. 

The newest estimates from Governor Hochul put the unlawful hashish market in New York at over 2,500 shops, a lot of which systematically evade crackdowns efforts attributable to baffling authorized loopholes and shady landlords. And this harms everybody.

Over the following decade, the hashish business will generate hundreds of jobs and billions in tax income. Hashish is a $33 billion business projected to develop to $150 billion by 2030. New York State is already shedding billions of {dollars} yearly by failing to tackle my unlawful rivals. We don’t know the place the unlawful shops are sourcing and buying their merchandise. They don’t seem to be following the rigorous security and safety protocols put in place by the Workplace of Hashish Administration and, greater than possible, will not be paying their justifiable share of taxes to both New York State or the Federal authorities. 


New York State's Office of Cannabis Management is tasked with issuing legal cannabis dispensary licenses. Many have been awarded, but few dispensaries have actually opened.
New York State’s Workplace of Hashish Administration is tasked with issuing authorized hashish dispensary licenses. Many have been awarded, however few dispensaries have really opened.
New York State Workplace of Hashish Administration

We’re competing in opposition to the hundreds of unlawful outlets which can be promoting quicker, cheaper, and with no oversight. That hurts our full-time staff who obtain revenue sharing and full medical health insurance, and it hurts our beneficiary associate STRIVE and its mission is to scale back jail recidivism. Couple that with the shortage of client training on what’s authorized and what’s not, and you’ve got a near-impossible path to profitability (or accountability).

It’s time to take motion. We want extra authorized shops to open. They should generate extra native tax income. And we’d like native farmers to profit from rising authorized hashish. We should help small-sized hashish companies to flourish whereas benefiting worthy social causes. 


One of the estimated 2,500 marijuana product shops operating in New York City without a license, which not only rob the city and state of much-needed tax revenue, but compromises product quality and safety.
One of many estimated 2,500 marijuana product outlets working in New York Metropolis and not using a license, which not solely rob town and state of much-needed tax income, however compromises product high quality and security.
Helayne Seidman

All that is doable, however it’s additionally expensive. I’ve invested in over 150 firms, specializing in feminine, black, and brown founders. However establishing a authorized store in NYC has been exceptionally irritating.

Assuming you’ll be able to really receive a license, you want a deep understanding of the tax code — regardless of the shortage of tax deductions afforded to some other small enterprise. On the Federal degree, a regulation referred to as 280E forbids hashish retailer operators from deducting bizarre enterprise bills since hashish remains to be a Schedule I managed substance.


The author, a serial entrepreneur, says setting up a legal cannabis operation in New York City has been one of the most onerous experiences of her professional life. Beyond her illegal competitors, she worries that those who are intended to benefit most from legal pot will be unable to partake in the profits.
The writer, a serial entrepreneur, says establishing a authorized hashish operation in New York Metropolis has been one of the crucial onerous experiences of her skilled life. Past her unlawful rivals, she worries that those that are supposed to profit most from authorized pot might be unable to partake within the earnings.
Courtesy of Joanne Wilson

Then comes the operation prices, together with a whole bunch of safety cameras that run tens of hundreds of {dollars} to put in and function, plus a strong full-time safety staff, each required by regulation. Then you definitely want stock administration software program as a result of every transaction should be meticulously reported per the Workplace of Hashish Administration, and that’s costly. You’ll be able to’t lose a single bud with out repercussions. 

Now we’re on to pricing. As a result of there aren’t any tax deductions allowed, the worth of hashish merchandise are larger than these within the unlawful market. If the federal government had taxed tech start-ups the identical manner they’re taxing hashish startups, I assure we might not have Google.  


Despite initial waffling, Gov. Hochul has recently announced new crackdowns on illegal pot operations.
Regardless of preliminary waffling, Gov. Hochul has lately introduced new crackdowns on unlawful pot operations.
Paul Martinka

I’ve by no means been a lot of a rule follower, however in relation to hashish and taxes, I’m buttoned up – and past. Why are unlawful dispensaries allowed to revenue with out following the principles? Why aren’t they required to safe a license and act responsibly? There may be loads of market share for everybody. Let’s help a brand new business by empowering individuals who’ve carried out issues the best manner. 

The grass can definitely be greener. 

Joanne Wilson is the Founding father of Gotham, Founding father of Gotham Gal Ventures, Co-Chair of Gotham Provides and Co-Founding father of the Ladies’s Entrepreneur Pageant.